8 Questions Google Says to Ask an SEO, Answered

David TonicDavid Tonic•SEO•8 min read•Updated Nov 17, 2026

By David Tonic, Founder, Tonic Enterprises

Google publishes its own list of questions to ask before you hire an SEO. There are eight. Most agencies never answer them in public, so we will, one by one, with each question quoted word for word from Google Search Central.

The short version: no one can guarantee you a #1 ranking, you should always own your own accounts, and any SEO worth hiring can show you their work and explain the work they do and why.

A quick note on who’s answering. Tonic Enterprises has done SEO since 2014. Based in Lake Mary, Florida, with clients in Florida, New York and Illinois. Our work includes industries where a careless claim can get you in trouble (law firms, medical practices, home services, wealth management). We sell SEO, so read this as a vendor talking. The questions are Google’s. The answers are ours.

1. “Can you show me examples of your previous work and share some success stories?”

Yes, and you should be able to check them yourself. A screenshot in a sales deck is easy to fake. A ranking you can look up, a business you can call, or a Google Business Profile (GBP) you can see is not.

What we show on a first call:

  • Our published moving company case study: +39% organic traffic value, 210 backlinks from 39 trusted domains, and 36 new AI citations across ChatGPT, Perplexity, and other AI search tools
  • A sample monthly report, with names removed, so you can see exactly what you’d get

One caveat we always give: many of our clients work in regulated fields like law and healthcare, and some prefer not to be named. When that’s the case, we show the work without the name and tell you why.

2. “Do you follow the Google Search Essentials (previously known as Webmaster Guidelines)?”

Yes, and it’s the cheapest question on this list to test. Ask an SEO to name one tactic they won’t use because it breaks Google’s rules. If they can’t name one, they either don’t know the rules or don’t follow them.

3. “What kind of results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe? How do you measure your success?”

No one can promise you a ranking, and Google says so in plain words: “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.” (Guaranteed rankings are one of the common SEO myths we hear most.) What we can promise is the work, a starting baseline, and an honest read on what moved.

In our experience, timing depends on where you start:

Starting pointWhen you usually see movement
GBP fixes (wrong hours, category, phone)Often within weeks
Map pack rankings (the 3 businesses Google shows with the map) in a moderately competitive cityA few months
Organic rankings for competitive service keywordsSix months or more
Mentions in AI answers (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews)Usually follows organic and off-site mentions

That’s why our managed programs run on 6- or 12-month agreements. Real SEO compounds, and a 30-day test mostly measures noise.

How we measure success, every month:

  • Leads first: calls and form fills, not just traffic
  • Rankings: map pack and organic positions for the keywords that bring in business
  • AI visibility: we run your target keywords through ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini and log who gets cited, plus AI referral traffic in GA4 (Google Analytics 4, Google’s free website analytics)
  • Reporting: a monthly report with a recorded video walkthrough from your campaign manager, explaining what changed and why

4. “What’s your experience in my industry?”

Our deepest experience is in industries where marketing has rules: law firms, medical practices, HVAC and home services, and wealth management. In those fields, a single overpromising sentence on a page can create real risk. Lawyer advertising rules (like New York’s Rule 7.1 and the Florida Bar’s advertising rules) and FTC guidance shape what we write, so compliance review is part of our content process, not an afterthought.

If your industry isn’t on that list, ask any SEO the same follow-up: “What’s one thing about marketing in my industry that most agencies get wrong?” A real answer tells you more than a client logo.

5. “What’s your experience in my country/city?”

Our clients are in Florida, New York and Illinois, and local search works differently in each. What wins the map pack in Lake Mary is different from what wins it in Chicago, and an SEO should be able to name your real local competitors on the first call.

6. “What’s your experience developing international sites?”

Honestly, limited. Our work is U.S. local and regional search. If you need multi-country or multi-language SEO, hire a specialist for that piece. An agency that says yes to everything is a red flag of its own.

7. “How long have you been in business?”

Tonic Enterprises opened in March 2014, and our founder has worked in digital marketing for more than 20 years. Longevity alone doesn’t prove anything. But an agency that has survived more than a decade of Google updates has had to adapt without shortcuts, because shortcuts tend to get caught.

8. “How can I expect to communicate with you? Will you share with me all the changes you make to my site, and provide detailed information about your recommendations and the reasoning behind them?”

You get a monthly report with a recorded video walkthrough, plus strategy calls with your campaign manager on our managed SEO programs. Between reports, you can reach us by email or phone. Ask any SEO the same question, and ask who exactly you’ll talk to. “Our team” is not an answer.

And yes, we share the work. Your monthly report shows the work we completed and the reasoning behind it. If we recommend something we can’t do ourselves (say, a coding fix your developer has to make), we say so and write it up so your developer can act on it.

Three ownership rules we follow with every client:

1

You own your accounts. Google Search Console (Google’s free tool that shows how your site does in search), Google Analytics and your GBP stay in your name. We ask for access, never ownership.

2

Audits get read-only access. Google’s own advice: “only grant read access to Search Console (at this stage, don’t grant them write access).” We agree, and our TechSight Audit works that way.

3

If you leave, your accounts, website content and listings stay yours.

Google’s AI question

Google’s page also covers AI search, in its list of things to check about an SEO’s recommendations: “If they have advice on optimizing for AI experiences (also known as “AEO” “GEO” services), is their advice aligned with Google Search’s official guidance on optimizing for generative AI features?”

Our answer: there’s no secret trick for getting into ChatGPT or Google’s AI Overviews. AI answers pull heavily from pages that already rank and from businesses that are mentioned across the web. So the work is mostly good SEO done well: clear answers near the top of the page, real proof (named authors, original data, real reviews), and mentions on trusted sites. We go deeper in how to get cited in AI Overviews and ChatGPT. Anyone selling a shortcut into AI answers is selling something Google doesn’t endorse.

Red flags to watch for

  • Ranking guarantees. Google: “Beware of SEOs that claim to guarantee rankings, allege a “special relationship” with Google, or advertise a “priority submit” to Google.”
  • Accounts in the agency’s name. If you can’t log in to your own Search Console or GBP, you don’t control your marketing.
  • Out-of-the-blue emails. Google says: “Be wary of SEO firms and web consultants or agencies that email you out of the blue.” We do reach out to businesses sometimes. When we do, the email names one specific issue on your site or listing that you can check yourself, and it makes no promises. Hold every SEO who emails you to that standard.

Key takeaways

  • Use Google’s 8 questions in every agency interview, and judge the answers, not the sales deck.
  • No one can guarantee a #1 ranking. Treat any guarantee as a reason to walk.
  • Keep your Search Console, analytics and GBP in your own name.
  • Good AI search work is good SEO work. There’s no shortcut into ChatGPT.

Interviewing agencies now? Ask us all eight on a call. We’ll answer them with your site and your competitors on the screen, and you’ll leave with a short list of fixes whether or not you hire us.

Tonic Enterprises

1540 International Pkwy, Suite 2000, Lake Mary, FL 32746

Phone: 407-917-7211

Email: info@tonicenterprises.co

Website: www.tonicenterprises.co

FAQ

Can an SEO agency guarantee first place on Google?

No. Google states that no one can guarantee a #1 ranking, and it warns against SEOs who claim a special relationship with Google.

What should I own when I hire an SEO?

Your Search Console, Google Analytics, Google Business Profile (GBP), website content and listings. Give the agency access, not ownership.

How long does SEO take to work?

GBP fixes often show results within weeks. Competitive organic rankings usually take six months or more. Any timeline should come with a baseline you can check.

Do I need a separate agency for AI search like ChatGPT?

Usually not. Google says AI advice should match its official guidance, and AI answers lean on pages that already rank and businesses that are mentioned across the web.

Sources

  • Do you need an SEO?, Google Search Central, last updated June 5, 2026 (checked November 17, 2026)

David Tonic

David Tonic

Founder of Tonic Enterprises, with more than 20 years in digital marketing. He founded Tonic Enterprises in March 2014. Connect on LinkedIn

Related Tonic Enterprises services

Scroll to Top